Register or sign in now
Home > Projects > The Good Prison: Projects and partnerships
Email this page
Print this page

Members' Zone

Sheetal Champaneri, Rethink Mental Health
joined 6 days ago
Emma Fowle, Premier Christianity
joined 1 week ago
Vanda Perrett, HMYOI
joined 1 week ago
Caroline Edgerton, Croydon Council
joined 2 weeks ago
Naomi Key-Field, 4th Dwarf
joined 3 weeks ago

News from Lemos&Crane

Hate crimes are not just about race and not just about hate

25 years of public debate and professional reflection on the causes and responses to crimes of intolerance


This article by Gerard Lemos is from a new book, Curing Violence:How we can be a less violent society 


The emergence of ‘hate crime’

In 1993, the public's attention was conclusively drawn to racially motivated hate crimes by the death of Stephen Lawrence, a black teenager out for the evening with his friend Duwayne Brooks, who was stabbed and killed by a group of white young men.  Largely through the determined and persistent campaigning of Stephen's parents, Doreen and Neville Lawrence, and their supporters, the case and the inadequate police response which failed for many years to bring anyone to trial (only two of the alleged perpetrators were convicted many years after the murder) became a cause celebre.

Following the murder, a much wider public debate took flight about the state of race relations in the UK and, in particular, the behaviour and attitudes of the Metropolitan Police to crimes when the victim was black and the perpetrators were white.  Eventually, a public inquiry was launched chaired by Sir William Macpherson who confirmed, among many other findings, that the police were in his view 'institutionally racist'. This term was championed by campaigners to describe the wider interaction of prejudice and discrimination in organisations which in the case of the police led them to take crimes committed against black people less than seriously, while they were all too ready to suspect black people of crimes, often with little justification.

But the tragic death of Stephen Lawrence was certainly not the first high profile racially motivated crime. Nor was it the first time that officialdom, in particular the police and the prosecuting authorities, had been enjoined to take crimes motivated by prejudice and discrimination more seriously, to recognise the nature of the motive and to seek sentences for conviction which gave weight to the added importance of the racist motive, in order to both set an example to others as well as to draw the attention of the perpetrator to the additional seriousness of their crime. 

Violent crimes were also not the only cause of concern.  Neighbour disputes, which were tremendously intimidating for the victims for example or the persistent shouting of intimidating and racist verbal abuse at Asian mothers as they took their children to local schools, or at the other extreme, harassment and attacks by neo-fascist groups (such as the now largely defunct British National Party and National Front), also served to reduce the lives of some black and minority ethnic people,  families and communities to intolerable levels of fear and stress.

These other incidents, which did not fall so squarely into the definitions of crimes to be investigated and prosecuted by the police, often went unaddressed by the authorities, not just the police and the prosecutors, but also social landlords.  The British Crime Survey since the 1980s has persistently found that some individuals and groups experienced attacks and harassment at levels of frequency which were way in excess of any serious attempts to deal with these incidents, much less to put a lasting end to the harassment, abuse and attacks. 

The evolution of ‘hate crime’

As time has gone on, it has also become clear that black and minority ethnic people are not the only people to be targeted for violent crimes for reasons of intolerance. Lesbians and gay men have also been targets, notably in the nail bomb attack on the Admiral Duncan pub in Soho in 1999, trans-gender people and people with physical and learning disabilities are all victims of crimes motivated by prejudice, intolerance, the perception of a particular group as inferior, weak and therefore deserving of denigration and exploitation in some cases.  Religion can also be a motivator of intolerance and aggression, now commonly characterised by the term 'Islamophobia. The 2017 attack on the Finsbury Park Mosque by a man driving into a group of worshippers serves as a case in point.

Understanding ‘hate crime’

Whether 'hate' is an accurate description of the variety of motives in these cases is debatable.  Without doubt, however, intolerance, prejudice and discrimination were important features both of the manner and the matter of the crime.  How do we then derive a more nuanced set of interpretations of these types of violent incidents in ways that will help us both to prevent incidents occurring in the first place and responding effectively when incidents are committed?  Researchers (such as Levin and McDevitt of Northeastern University) have sought to derive meaningful typologies to help understand motivation and its relation to different types of incidents. 

Mission offenders are those motivated by prejudices so strong that they feel themselves to be on a ‘crusade’. These are extreme emotions that appear to justify extreme actions in the minds of their promoters.  Terrorism can be seen as this most extreme form of hate crime.  Fortunately, it is also the rarest.

Thrill-seekers are often immature and motivated by a warped sense of what will bring excitement and drama to their lives, of which the complaint is often that they are ‘boring’.  Prejudice does not necessarily run very deep in this group, but the willingness to act on impulse and take risks without regard to consequences often amplifies their latent prejudices into acts of aggression, frequently perpetrated under the influence of alcohol and in groups, egged on and congratulated by one another.

Defensive attackers are people who feel that there is something that they need to protect – the traditional (and perhaps excluding) lifestyle and culture of their neighbourhood or removing a (usually erroneously) perceived danger to their children’s safety. They tend to persist in the belief that their actions are justified even when challenged by the authorities and assert that many others in similar situations would do the same did they but have the courage of their convictions.

Responding to ‘hate crime’

The salience of this typology is not just for the purposes of academic tidying up.  Which type of offence is being committed speaks strongly to what would be the most effective official response. 

The increasing recognition of racially motivated and other hate crimes in the 1980s and 1990s led to an acceptance by legislators and courts that an intolerant motive aggravated the crime and therefore attracted a higher tariff. This was intended to be both penal and exemplary.  While that was an understandable response to campaigning pressure, it did not really answer the post-conviction question of who should do what to seek to make a lasting beneficial change to offenders’ behaviour.

Important work in this regard was done by Liz Dixon at the London Probation Service and Andy Stelman, then part of Merseyside Probation Service, to address explicitly and constructively the motives, attitudes, behaviour and consequences of racist offending.  They focused on strengthening feelings of positive identity and self-esteem such that others were not seen either as a threat or so weak (even weaker than your own secret self) that they could be attacked with impunity. They also focused on positive association, good friends and engaging social lives and only lastly on the further risks and consequences up to and including imprisonment for further trouble with the law. Perhaps most importantly they placed considerable emphasis on inculcating empathy for the victims.

In my own work on attacks on people with learning disabilities, I have noted both common characteristics among those likely to be the victims and the perpetrators as well as trends in the nature of the crimes.  Financial and sexual exploitation appear to come high on the list of perpetrators’ intentions and actions. Cruelty and exploitation is therefore perhaps a more accurate description of what is going on than hate crimes.  The vulnerability of the victims appears to stem from their loneliness and sense of exclusion from an unwelcoming and intolerant wider society. Indifference seems to prevail even among those who are not themselves actively cruel or exploitative. Remedies for that exclusion lie in civil society and, in our work, we have focused on the opportunities offered by the arts and faith communities, as well as the importance of financial capability as an enabler of safe independence.

One could also focus on sport, rambling, cycling clubs or any number of other social groupings which speak to the quieter aspects of British civic life which repeatedly proves itself more durable than more high profile but evanescent activities driven by politics, celebrity and media.  These everyday person to person activities are also less susceptible to the undoubted dangers which sit alongside the undoubted benefits offered by online experience. Notwithstanding the huge benefits of the newer technologies, they are also a recent and rapidly amplifying zone of vocal intolerance and hostility, notably for example in relation to anti-Semitism.

Rethinking ‘hate crime’

One recognises the value of a term such as ‘hate crimes’ as a tool for campaigning. Sometimes there is a need for strong language to overcome official indifference or intransigence, but the term hate crimes does not work as a policy framework beyond the recognition of the need for a higher tariff by the courts.

The broad front of civil society as well as criminal justice responses I have articulated will in the end have more lasting benefit. These engage criminal justice actors, in particular probation officers, but even more so voluntary groups and the wider community.  The meta-goal here is that prosecution and punishment are only an educative starting point for policy intention. Victims and members of vulnerable communities will feel infinitely more satisfied with a convincing assurance that the hostile, aggressive or intolerant behaviour can be prevented, stopped and will not recur. That is always more effective in bringing closure and a lasting feeling of security than the simple sight of an offender being locked up.    




No comments yet
Please signin to add a comment

Beethoven, Steve Reich and Gerhard Richter in HMP Whitemoor

Films Inside: Fatherhood in films at HMPs Brinsford, Featherstone and Oakwood

Tuning Up: Britten Sinfonia working with 30 prisoner and staff musicians at HMP Whitemoor

Life Beyond Crime: What do those at risk of offending, prisoners and ex-offenders need to learn?

Vanessa Bell at Dulwich Picture Gallery: Re-imagine artists responding to her work through textile printing

A lovely video inspired by the art of Louise Bourgeois made by Re-imagine artists at Tate Modern

Reflections on the Gilbert Collection at the V&A

V&A Colour Space in the Gilbert Collection of gold and silver miniature boxes – November and December 2016

Working together to improve criminal justice: Monument Fellowship launched

Prisoners making spectacles for prisoners

Growing Localities Awards Ceremony 2016 at the Horniman Museum

Homing retired greyhounds at HMP Littlehey

Durham University students studying with prisoners at HMP Durham

LSO musicians giving workshops at London special schools

Disabled adults making music with prisoners at HMP Bronzefield

Evaluating Social Action for Rehabilitation - Khulisa Rehabilitation Social Action programmes

The magic of making: Why art matters for prisoners

Relaxed Talk and Draw at the National Gallery - Week 2

Relaxed Talk and Draw at the National Gallery - Week 1

Resilient Resettlement project started

The Knowledge: Learning from London

Inside and Out: the experiences of LGBT prisoners in prison

Update: Access to the arts, galleries and museums for people with learning disabilities

Seminar: Music and orchestral activities in prisons and YOIs

Call for good practice: arts and homelessness

Growing Localities Awards Ceremony

Conference review: Empowering homeless people to make resilient and lasting life changes

Establishing dog training projects in prisons and YOIs

Online Training: Adult safeguarding in social housing

Landmark Supreme Court ruling for homeless people

UPDATE: Bringing Orchestras into Prisons and YOIs

UPDATE: Catholic prisoners' experience of Catholic ministry in prison

Gamelan performance with Good Vibrations

Improving access to digital technology for homeless and ex-homeless people

Growing Localities Awards celebratory event

Tate Local Network: learning disability

Brazil/UK Arts and Homelessness seminar: 'Why do we engage homeless people with the arts?'

The London Symphony Orchestra's Create programme for adults with learning disabilities

Adult Safeguarding in Prison

The Care Act 2014 and the voluntary sector working in criminal justice

Inspection of the treatment of offenders with learning disabilities

The Care Act 2014 comes into force

London Symphony Orchestra's work with special schools

Catholic prisoners' experience of Catholic ministry in prison

Intoart at the V&A

Heart n Soul at the British Museum

Good Prison - Seminar with National Museums Liverpool

Improving access to the arts, museums and galleries: seminar report

Resilient resettlement for ex-homeless people

Tackling forced labour in the UK: new project with Thames Reach

Supporting spiritual aspirations of people with learning disabilities: new collaborative project

NEW Research: Catholic chaplaincy in prison

Research launch seminar: Trends and Friends

Welcome to LiteracyActionNet

Grow Wild UK free seed kits

Heart n Soul: creative sessions for adults with learning disabilities

The Good Prison: expression of interest

FREE SEMINAR: UK museums working with prisons and young offender institutions

NEW PAPER: Re-imagine: Improving access to the arts, galleries and museums for people with learning disabilities

Improving access to the arts, museums and galleries: seminar report

Upcoming seminar: Digital empowerment of homeless and vulnerable people

Resilient resettlement for ex-homeless people

Exploitation and forced labour of homeless and vulnerable people: Briefing Paper

Museums and prisons seminar - 24 Feb 2015

Grow Wild UK to distribute free seed kits

Empowering homeless people through digital technology: report due early 2015

Tackling forced labour in the UK: new project with Thames Reach

Supporting spiritual aspirations of people with learning disabilities: new collaborative project

Growing Localities Awards 2014/2015 - NOW OPEN

'Quids In': building financial capability and confidence for adults with learning disabilities: new collaborative project

London Symphony Orchestra encourages adults with learning disabilities

Digital Empowerment Awards announced

Growing Localities Awards announced

Homeless and vulnerable people in forced labour in the UK: developing and disseminating good practice in prevention and casework

People with learning disabilities and museums, galleries and performing arts: re-imagining access and participation

Digital Empowerment Shortlist announced

New free website: Action Against Cruelty

Empowering homeless people through digital technology: literature review

New and improved LiteracyActionNet website

Ethos and Practice: Comparing approaches to working with vulnerable people

Research launch: Re-imagining Futures

Lost and Found: the Next Stage Begins

LankellyChase Digital Empowerment Awards Open for Entries

Lemos&Crane speak at Thames Reach Digital Empowerment seminar

Get Online Week and Digital Empowerment Awards

The End of the Chinese Dream by Gerard Lemos: paperback edition

Coming Soon: Growing Localities Awards 2013/2014

Coming Soon: Digital Empowerment Awards

Improving literacy outcomes for children with dyslexia/SpLD

The spiritual value of night shelters for homeless people

New research: Digital technology and homelessness

Action Against Cruelty

New report: 'Bad Weather, Good Habits: encouraging social housing tenants to save more'

Sex and Relationships Education for Adults and Young People with Learning Disabilities

Contact us
Read about us
Privacy and Data Protection Statement
Terms of use
Copyright © Lemos&Crane 2021